My Watch Pet Peeves
Fourteen small things brands get wrong, and the one that makes me walk away
By @midlifecrisiswatches · · 7 min readThis post started with a YouTube video. The team at Fratello put out an episode of Fratello Talks called Our Watch Pet Peeves Vol. II, with Nacho, RJ, and Daan spending forty minutes on the small things that bug them about watches. Some of theirs are mine too but most of it just made me start my own list.
A pet peeve is not a deal breaker for me. I own watches that commit several of the offenses below, and I wear them anyway. With that said, something else the watch has makes up so significantly for these pet peeves that I convince myself to overlook them.
I ended up with fourteen pet peeves. Half of them are about how the watch attaches to my wrist. Regular readers will not be surprised. I love straps, and I have written about them more than once: Watch Strap 101 on what separates a $40 strap from a $400 one, The Strap Rabbit Hole Has a New Accomplice, and the bracelet questions in this AMA recap.
The strap or bracelet is the part of a watch you touch most and also allows you to personalize your watch and make it your own. For those who cannot build a piece unique, this is the closest we can come and frankly, it's rather simple.
Start with the strap
The bad factory strap. A $15,000 watch arrives on a strap that feels like a laminated business card. Stiff, shiny, and creased within a week. The brand saved a few dollars. I then spend a couple hundred replacing it. If the strap is the first thing every owner swaps, the brand has a product problem and has decided to hand it to the customer.
I replace straps on the majority of my watches. With that said, I was at Shreve, Crump, and Low recently and took a watch from a highly sought after indy out of the pre-owned case and tried it on. The strap on the watch wouldn't even bend around my wrist without a bit of pressure. Right then and there, it was a deal breaker for me. I know I said these do not turn into deal breakers but this just was so bad... The watch itself was $35,000 - you'd think the OEM strap would be decent.
Quick release that isn't quick. The idea is good. Change straps with no tool. Then a brand invents its own system and it takes longer than a spring bar tool would have. The cheap versions are worse. The little tab snaps off and the spring bar is now trapped between the lugs with nothing to grab. The Fratello guys pointed to Cartier as a brand that got this right, which tells you it can be done. I find the quick release on my Ulysses Nardin FreakX are not that good. Granted, it's a bracelet, but still, it has the pins you press together and it should be easy.
19mm and 21mm lugs. The strap world runs on 18, 20, and 22. Pick an odd width and the owner gets a fraction of the selection, or squeezes a 20 into a 19 and pretends not to notice. Nobody ever chose a watch because it had 21mm lugs. Grand Seiko and Zenith are guilty of this.
Then the bracelet
No taper. A bracelet that is 20mm at the lugs and 20mm at the clasp isn't something that I'm interested in. Taper is what makes a bracelet feel like jewelry instead of hardware. You notice the missing taper most at a desk, where all that extra steel sits under your wrist.
Pin-and-collar sizing. Screws exist. I can size a screwed bracelet at the kitchen table in five minutes. Pin-and-collar means tiny tubes that vanish into the carpet and a trip to someone with the right tool. Friction pins are barely better. Why can't we just use screws?
The butterfly clasp that closes one way. Two wings. One carries a little plaque with the logo. Close them in the wrong order and the clasp won't shut. I get it wrong about half the time. I don't need a logo at the bottom of the clasp... and lets make those clasps easier to close.
What you feel and hear
Loud rotors. A rotor I can hear across a quiet room and sometimes with that grind-y sound. Some collectors say the noise reminds them the watch is mechanical. I knew that already. I did my research and purchased it. It makes a watch sound materially cheaper.
A crown with no feel. A screw-down crown should tell your fingers something. You push, it catches, it tightens, it stops. Some crowns spin with no resistance at all, and you never know whether the threads have caught or you are about to cross them. The crown is the one place you put your hands on the mechanism. It should feel like something. I also like when I'm winding my watch, spinning my crown, and it gets a bit harder to turn as I transfer power. This helps me understand if the watch is wound.
What you see
Date fonts that don't match. The dial has its own typography. Someone chose it carefully. Then the date wheel shows up in a generic font from the movement supplier, as if a different company printed it. Once you see it, you keep seeing it.
Misaligned bezels and chapter rings. The marker at 12 that sits a hair left of the triangle on the bezel almost showcasing poor quality control. Ugh.
Thickness creep. A dress watch used to slide under a cuff. Now plenty of them run 12 or 13mm and are still considered dress watches. My own line is about 12mm for most watches. Thin is hard. That is why it is worth paying for.
The buying experience
AD games. Buy three watches you don't want to earn the right to buy the one you do. I come from marketing and investing, so I understand allocating scarce product. What I don't understand is calling it a relationship. A relationship goes both ways. I also do not want to buy jewelry to have access to watches. A non-starter for me.
Limited editions of several thousand. If there are 5,000 of them, it is a production run and numbering the caseback doesn't change the math. Real scarcity belongs to the watchmaker who can only finish twenty or forty pieces a year. Borrowing the word for a run of thousands of pieces is marketing.
Oversized boxes. A box the size of a toaster oven for a 38mm watch. It goes in a closet and stays there until I sell the watch, at which point it becomes shipping weight. I would take a good travel pouch and the difference put back into the watch. It's incredible to me to see how absurdly large some of these boxes are.
Still buying
None of these stop me from buying a watch but a bad strap is really, really, really bad. Actually, you know what will absolutely prevent me from buying a watch? AD games. I just don't play them. There are plenty of other ways to purchase watches out there... games are unnecessary.
Thanks to Nacho, RJ, and Daan for the prompt.